Jemima Goldsmith challenges ‘Pro-Israel’ and ‘Pro-Palestine’ labels

Entertainment Dec, 12 2023
Jemima Goldsmith challenges ‘Pro-Israel’ and ‘Pro-Palestine’ labels
  • 194
  • 0

Renowned screenwriter and filmmaker Jemima Goldsmith is trying to be an advocate for discussions surrounding the rise of antisemitism and Islamophobia. In a recent post on X, she challenged the binary narrative of being either "pro-Israel" or "pro-Palestine," emphasising the need for a more comprehensive approach.

Jemima took to the site formerly known as Twitter to state, "I really don't like the terms, 'pro-Israel' or 'pro- Palestine,' as it infers the choice has to be binary. You can be pro-Israel's right to exist in safety and pro-Palestinian freedom. Those two things are not only mutually inclusive; they are contingent upon one another."

Moreover, recently, in an article penned for The Independent, Jemima delved into the challenging territory of antisemitism and Islamophobia. The piece was titled, "I have Muslim and Jewish family - I want to talk about antisemitism and Islamophobia." Jemima shared her personal encounters with antisemitism, recounting how her Jewish identity became a tool to attack her ex-husband, Imran Khan, in Pakistan. She revealed that opposition politicians and a partisan media fabricated Zionist conspiracy theories, leading to decades of threats, violence, and a failed assassination attempt. Khan highlighted the dangerous intertwining of prejudice and politics, illustrating the real-world consequences of bigotry.

"Antisemitism is on the rise everywhere and it is terrifying for Jewish people," stated Jemima's article. "There is also an under-acknowledged problem with antisemitism within Muslim communities. I have had first-hand experience of this, as my Jewishness was used as a baton to beat my politician ex-husband Imran Khan, in Pakistan, where Zionist conspiracy theories about me were fabricated - and fervour was whipped up by opposition politicians and by a partisan media."

The article continued, "This led to decades of death threats and threats of rape and violence towards me and my children, which continue to this day. Despite our divorce, this culminated for Imran in a failed assassination attempt last year. After the attack, the would-be assassin declared in his confessional video that the motive for the shooting was (Imran's) 'acceptance of Israel.'"

Jemima drew attention to the usage of terms such as "Zionism" and "Islamism," emphasising how they are "used by bigots as a fig leaf to express what is, in fact, prejudice against Jews or Muslims as a group." She acknowledged that accusations of antisemitism are sometimes wielded to stifle criticism of the Israeli government. Conversely, she advocated for the ability to criticise Israel's actions without being falsely labelled antisemitic.

"It is also true that accusations of antisemitism have been used by some as a cudgel to shut down debate and criticism of the Israeli government. Just as we can criticise the Islamic Republic of Pakistan's government without being Islamophobic, people must be able to express criticism of Israel's actions in Gaza without being falsely labelled antisemitic. Allowing anyone who criticises Israel to be called 'antisemitic' just makes it easier for others to dismiss antisemitism, which only undermines the gravity of a very real and virulent problem," read her article.

The ex-wife of the former premier of Pakistan also pointed out that "Muslim hatred is also on the rise." She said in her piece, "...it affects many people I love - including my children. In the US, in the last few weeks, three Palestinian students have been shot and a six-year-old boy was stabbed to death and his mother injured, because they were Muslim. Meanwhile, Trump contemplates reinstating his Muslim ban if he becomes president of the US once again and far-right parties with explicitly anti-Muslim agendas are, for the first time, winning elections in European countries."

She further stated, "And just as I have seen a reluctance on the part of some Muslim friends to recognise when antipathy to Israeli policy has become indistinguishable from broader attacks on Israelis or Jews, I have also witnessed a similar unwillingness amongst some of my Jewish friends to accept that Islamophobia is a real thing."

Published in The Daily National Courier, December, 13 2023

Like Business on Facebook, follow @DailyNCourier on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.

NC Big Stories

Bilawal stresses need to overcome national divisions for consensus

LAHORE: Pakistan People's Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari has said that deep-rooted divisions in the country remain the biggest obstacle to achieving consensus. During a meeting with party officials, senior PPP leaders  Sajjad-ul-Has...

CM Murad, Italian CG discuss investment, trade relations

KARACHI: Sindh Chief Minister (CM) Murad Ali Shah and the newly appointed Consul General of Italy Fabrizio agreed to further coordinate their efforts to facilitate investment in Sindh. In a meeting held here at CM House yesterday, the CM Sindh and It...

MQM-P leader writes to CJP over alarming rise in traffic fatalities

KARACHI: Muttahida Qaumi Movement Pakistan (MQM-P) leader and Deputy Parliamentary Leader in the Sindh Assembly, Taha Ahmed Khan, has written a letter to the Chief Justice of Pakistan, urging him to take suo motu notice of the rising number of deadly...

ECP disqualifies 24 ex-lawmakers

ISLAMABAD: The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) has disqualified 24 former members of the National and Provincial Assemblies for failing to submit their asset and liability declarations for the fiscal year 2022-2023, yesterday. According to an o...

More like this
Related

The secret behind Miley Cyrus’ latest artistic vision revealed

Miley Cyrus has just revealed a trailer for her upcoming film linked to her new album Something Beautiful. The trailer describes the film as “a unique visual experience” and “a one-of-a-kind pop opera” that will feature 13 tra...

Aamir Khan launches YouTube channel to reveal filmmaking secrets

Aamir Khan, one of Bollywood’s most celebrated actors, has launched a new YouTube channel called Aamir Khan Talkies, offering fans an exclusive look into the world of filmmaking. Known for his remarkable career and successful production venture...

Hania, Diljit movie set for release

Pakistani actor Hania Aamir is set to make her Indian film debut in Sardaar Ji 3, the latest installment of the popular Punjabi film franchise led by Diljit Dosanjh and Neeru Bajwa. The film, confirmed to release on June 27, 2025, has already generat...

Shoaib Malik celebrates Wife’s special day in style

Shoaib Malik and Sana Javed, who tied the knot last year, have often been in the spotlight due to their relationship. After a year of facing public scrutiny, the couple has been spotted together more frequently, with fans expressing their admiration...
Need Help? Chat with us